Variation in plot development has always been the strength of any game, making the passage less linear and allowing players to choose their path, and Fallout 4 is no exception. Having learned that Mayor McDonough is a synth during the In Sheep’s Clothing mission, Fallout 4 players no longer have doubts about what to do with him, but not everything is so simple.
Players who are able to pass the Speech Check so that this villain will let Piper go will then have a difficult choice. You can kill him on the spot, let him go, or bring him to a fair trial. In truth, your choice will not have much impact on the future of Mayor McDonough, but this decision may affect Sole Survivor to some extent.
Fallout 4: How To Turn On the Flashlight
An endless source of light will become a helpful ally during your travels, therefore, you should learn how to turn on your Flashlight in Fallout 4.
Fallout 4: Should You Kill Mayor McDonough or Let Him Go?
First of all, it is worth noting that, regardless of your decision, McDonough will lose his position as mayor and will no longer pose a threat to Diamond City. By letting him go, he will disappear forever, and the other two options lead to his death. In this situation, the only things you should consider when choosing are ethical preferences, your benefit, and the reaction of your companions and residents to your decision.
Based on the above, the best course of action for Mayor McDonough would be to give him a fair trial, and there are several reasons for this. Firstly, such a solution seems noble and fair, but more importantly, it will earn you more approval from your companions. Secondly, a fair trial for McDonough still means imminent death, so you can loot his body for consumables, caps, and Kellogg’s House Key. In addition, upon completion of the In Sheep’s Clothing mission, the residents of Diamond City will periodically begin to give you small gifts, which will be a pleasant permanent bonus.
Fallout 4: Best Armor Sets, Ranked
Fallout 4 contains many useful armor sets that players should definitely try to find, but these are arguably the best.
It is worth noting that if you decide to kill him, you will receive all the same benefits, except that, despite the evil nature of McDonough, your decision will not please most of the companions. Even if they understand that your decision is correct, they will be disappointed in you.
As for the third option, you shouldn’t choose it. Once you let him go, you will no longer see him, but this is hardly better than what alternative solutions offer. Eventually, this decision will not be of the liking of the majority of possible companions and the city residents. This option is suitable for those who are trying to complete the game with a minimum number of kills, but this is unlikely to be what a Fallout 4 player will be striving for.
This is all you need to know about what to do with Mayor McDonough during the mission In Sheep’s Clothing in Fallout 4. Your decision will not have a huge impact on the future plot. So, choose based on personal benefits and preferences.
Fallout 4
- Released
- November 10, 2015
