The newly re-released Pikmin 4 on the Switch 2 is being review-bombed, with players criticizing several aspects of its paid upgrade despite the original game’s positive reception. Released in 2023, Pikmin 4 was among Nintendo’s most acclaimed Switch exclusives, but its recently launched Switch 2 Edition is proving far more divisive.
Originally released on July 21, 2023, Pikmin 4 marked the first new numbered installment in Nintendo’s classic strategy series in a decade. The game received widespread praise for its colorful environments, accessible gameplay, and the introduction of Oatchi, an adorable canine companion who assists players throughout their adventure. On the original Switch, it currently holds an 87 Metascore and an 8.9 user score on Metacritic, reflecting its generally positive reception. Most recently, Nintendo released Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy on November 12, offering enhanced visuals and additional content for $9.99 to existing owners. However, the upgrade has quickly become a source of frustration for some longtime fans.
Pikmin 4’s Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Is Being Review Bombed
At the time of this writing, the Metacritic user reviews for Pikmin 4‘s Switch 2 Edition have been overwhelmingly negative, with the game receiving a user score of just 1.9 out of 10 from 306 ratings. This stands in sharp contrast to the original game’s 8.9 user score, as well as the new edition’s considerably more positive 83 Metascore from professional reviewers. Many negative fan reviews appear to question the value of the upgrade, with some players accusing Nintendo of making the game worse. One user, Kevosan, gave the release a 0/10 rating, stating the upgrade “actively makes the game worse” and criticized its performance and additional content.
Rearrange the movies into the correct US release order.
Sign in to claim your place on
the leaderboard!
Much of the current backlash centers on the Switch 2 Edition’s technical shortcomings, which seem to make this release arguably worse than Pikmin 4 on the original Nintendo Switch. Although the upgrade introduces native 4K resolution when docked, the game remains limited to 30 FPS and also lacks support for the console’s Joy-Con 2 mouse controls, which many fans expected would come naturally to a strategy game. More concerning are reports of longer loading times, with some players claiming that transitions between areas take significantly longer than on the original Switch. One user review claimed that certain loading screens had increased from approximately six seconds to more than 30 seconds, although the severity of these issues appears to vary between players.
Additionally, Pikmin 4‘s new Dandori Academy mode has also attracted criticism, particularly regarding how its content is being distributed. Nintendo has promised 72 challenge stages for Pikmin 4, but is releasing only six each month, meaning players cannot immediately access the full experience. Some fans have also criticized the mode for reusing environments and layouts from the original game rather than introducing entirely new locations. Beyond Dandori Academy, the upgrade adds voice commands for Oatchi and GameShare support for multiplayer Dandori Battles; however, these additions have done little to satisfy players who were primarily hoping for more substantial performance improvements in Pikmin 4.
Despite the overwhelmingly negative user ratings, professional reviews of Pikmin 4‘s Switch 2 Edition have been considerably more favorable. Many outlets have praised the improved visuals, Dandori Academy’s potential, and the relatively inexpensive upgrade price, particularly for newcomers experiencing Pikmin 4 for the first time. Some fans have also argued that the extremely low Metacritic ratings are excessive, given that the original game remains largely unchanged. Whether Nintendo addresses the reported performance issues remains to be seen, but the backlash demonstrates how even a well-received game can face criticism when its paid upgrade fails to meet expectations.

- Released
-
November 12, 2026
- ESRB
-
Everyone 10+ / Comic Mischief, Fantasy Violence
- Developer(s)
-
Nintendo EPD, Eighting
- Publisher(s)
-
Nintendo
- Multiplayer
-
Online Multiplayer, Local Multiplayer






Image via Nintendo
Image via Nintendo
Image via Nintendo