Some Super Mario Fans Are Really Not Happy About Birdo Being in the New Galaxy Movie

A discussion has sparked among Nintendo fans online following the inclusion of Birdo in a brand-new teaser for the upcoming Super Mario Galaxy Movie. In a trailer that dives deeper into Yoshi’s role in the sequel to 2023’s The Super Mario Bros. Movie, several characters can be seen making their debut in the cinematic adaptation of Super Mario Galaxy. One of these is Bowser Jr. as he takes on the main antagonist role from his father following Bowser’s defeat by Mario and company in the previous film.

Released during a surprise January Nintendo Direct, the trailer gives a sneak peek at the beloved figures fans can expect to see onscreen when the Super Mario Galaxy Movie releases on April 1. This includes Yoshi, Mario, Luigi, Toad, and even the Babies Mario and Luigi. Deep-cut characters for Super Mario enthusiasts, such as a Lakitu and Mouser, can be briefly spotted too. The previous Super Mario movie featured many classic enemies from the Nintendo games, like Sledge Bro, Kamek, and Chain Chomps, suggesting that the upcoming film may shine a light on underappreciated characters.

Where You Know The Super Mario Galaxy Movie’s Benny Safdie From

Bowser Jr will be voiced by Benny Safdie in The Super Mario Galaxy Movie, but fans may not be familiar with his past work as both an actor and writer.

Birdo’s Inclusion in Super Mario Galaxy Could Be Nod to Classic Mario Game

Among the debutants in the film adaptation of 2007’s Super Mario Galaxy, one character has drawn an unexpected surge of controversy: the occasionally underappreciated Birdo. The egg-firing, pink character, who first appeared all the way back in 1988’s Super Mario Bros. 2, can be seen attacking Princess Peach in an action sequence. This may suggest a potential role as a mini-antagonist within one of the film’s many galaxies. In a post on the Mario subreddit, user Inevitable-Charge76 shared examples of fan reactions to Birdo in the Super Mario Galaxy trailer, with one commenter referring to it as a disappointment and another querying why Nintendo would choose Birdo over a character like Toadette. Beloved characters like Wario and Daisy haven’t yet been revealed as part of the roster of characters, despite them being universally known to Super Mario fans and casual Nintendo players.

In spite of the reaction to Birdo’s upcoming appearance on film, many fans have shown appreciation for her role in Super Mario lore. A commenter on Reddit going by Thegoodgamer32 highlights that “she’s one of the oldest Mario characters…so it makes sense that she’d get in over some characters like Wario or Toadette.” The counter-voice in the community is celebrating Birdo’s appearance as a fun callback to older Mario titles, especially considering Super Mario Galaxy’s plethora of potential worlds to explore and pay tribute to. Fans have even considered other elements of the scene, like Mouser’s brief cameo and the slot machine, as an homage to Super Mario Bros. 2.

The divide caused by Birdo’s appearance in this Super Mario Galaxy Movie teaser taps into broader, ongoing discussions of her portrayal in the Nintendo franchise. Not much is known about Birdo in comparison to her compatriots in the Super Mario franchise. It’s unknown at this time whether Super Mario Galaxy will expand on Birdo’s story, but movies based on video games frequently diverge from the source material. A recent example of this is the recently released film Return to Silent Hill, which was criticized for being an unfaithful interpretation of Silent Hill 2.

mario-galaxy-movie-reveals-who-is-playing-rosalina-and-bowser-jr-game-rant-peach-ninjis

As for the Super Mario Galaxy Movie teaser and its presentation of Birdo, it’s evident that fans deeply care about their favorite characters from Nintendo’s film universe. While the financial triumph of The Super Mario Bros. Movie speaks to it being a major success with cinemagoers, what remains to be seen is how the animated sequel will appeal to hardcore Nintendo fans. It may be difficult to balance the sprawling cast of characters while satisfying enthusiasts and casual viewers alike, and Birdo’s controversial inclusion already demonstrates how this debate could expand on the film’s release.