Close Menu
Best in Gaming
  • Home
  • News
  • PC Games
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Nintendo
  • Mobile
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Press Release
What's On
Ex-Nintendo Leads Now Pitch a Smash Bros. Melee Remake, but One Problem Hasn’t Changed

Ex-Nintendo Leads Now Pitch a Smash Bros. Melee Remake, but One Problem Hasn’t Changed

19 November 2026
More Mass Layoffs At Ubisoft Underway, Affecting Two Of Its Biggest Studios

More Mass Layoffs At Ubisoft Underway, Affecting Two Of Its Biggest Studios

19 November 2026
CNN Calls GTA 6 The ‘Most Intense Version Of Pac-Man’

CNN Calls GTA 6 The ‘Most Intense Version Of Pac-Man’

19 November 2026
Mass Effect 5 Is Canceled, but Ex-BioWare RPG Exodus Has One Thing Shepard Never Had

Mass Effect 5 Is Canceled, but Ex-BioWare RPG Exodus Has One Thing Shepard Never Had

19 November 2026
WoW: Forever Wants To Get Rid Of The Idea Of “BiS” Gear

WoW: Forever Wants To Get Rid Of The Idea Of “BiS” Gear

19 November 2026
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Best in Gaming
  • Home
  • News
  • PC Games
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Nintendo
  • Mobile
  • Editor’s Picks
  • Press Release
Best in Gaming
Home » Ex-Nintendo Leads Now Pitch a Smash Bros. Melee Remake, but One Problem Hasn’t Changed
Nintendo

Ex-Nintendo Leads Now Pitch a Smash Bros. Melee Remake, but One Problem Hasn’t Changed

News RoomBy News Room19 November 20265 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Ex-Nintendo Leads Now Pitch a Smash Bros. Melee Remake, but One Problem Hasn’t Changed

Nintendo has been on fire as of late, with so many amazing first-party titles and remakes of iconic games releasing year-round. However, one franchise is still lacking a next-generation release, and as some ex-Nintendo leads have discussed (via GamesRadar), a Super Smash Bros. Melee remake may be exactly what the company needs to reignite its fighting game community, though it does come with some potential flaws that Nintendo is still yet to solve.

Many fans have been waiting for close to a decade for the next premier Nintendo fighter, and while it would be great to see a new mainline entry, a Super Smash Bros. Melee remake would certainly fill the void. At the same time, remaking a multiplayer game with an active community, albeit a small one, may alienate that player base even more, with diehards revolting against the change and newcomers opting for the more polished game that Nintendo may very well remove a lot of the fun quirks and tech from.

Nintendo Remade Ocarina of Time With Zelda’s Future in Mind, But Not the Way You’d Expect

Nintendo has revealed a surprising reason for remaking Ocarina of Time, and it has little to do with nostalgia or the series’ anniversary.

A Super Smash Bros. Melee Remake Would Be A Gamble For Nintendo

Remasters and remakes have become all the rage over the past decade or so, and it seems like every other franchise is getting a revival in one way or another. For Nintendo, they are already showing that they are more than happy to return to their classics, and have found massive success with games like Ocarina of Time, proving that remakes can be just as, if not more, profitable than mainline releases. Yet the story is very different for multiplayer games, such as Super Smash Bros. Melee, where if a remake pops up, then your players have to choose between two very distinct experiences, one with old-school-feeling mechanics and one with a more modern approach.

Remaking a multiplayer game with an active community, albeit a small one, may alienate that player base even more.

And judging by the existing Super Smash Bros. Melee community, change is not exactly something they are overly open to. You can see that purely based on the fact that people are still playing and competing in a 20+ year-old game on a retired console, without any HD remakes or modern ports since then, and if Nintendo is to show that they value that side of their player base in any way, then they need to be very careful about how they go about the future of Smash, especially if it means the path of remakes.

There is also the mechanical component to consider when talking about remaking PvP games versus singleplayer ones. In Ocarina of Time’s case, the game is fundamentally the same, just with so many more convenient mechanics and gameplay elements that allow the core story and world to shine even brighter, although there are still plenty of people who prefer the nostalgia and aesthetic of the original. Turning to Super Smash Bros. Melee, there is an insane amount of depth, from L-cancelling to wavedashing, that would likely be removed in a remake, which would take away a level of skill that so many players have come to adore, despite them being unintended mechanics, so it is up to Nintendo to decide how much of the original’s DNA would be translated into the modern day.

The Future of Super Smash Bros.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate released all the way back in 2018, and since then we have had several Switch rereleases and an entirely new console, alongside 100s of first-party titles across every exclusive franchise imaginable. But the silence around the new Smash game is starting to become deafening, even more so now that remakes are on the table, which opens the door for Nintendo to release more than just new entries.

The problem is the connection between player bases and the different games, as no matter how much time has passed, there are still players enjoying their time on the older titles, and I imagine that if a new Super Smash Bros. game releases, then there will be plenty of people who stick around in Ultimate as well. There is potential for a Switch 2 version of Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, which could be a nice way for Nintendo to bide their time while they make a decision about the future of the franchise. Yet at the same time, a re-release with a minor graphical and performance bump will feel a little lackluster, particularly when the rest of the Nintendo family has been treated so well.

It’s a lot of unknowns, and there are a lot of hurdles that Nintendo needs to jump through in order to make the largest number of people happy, but at the end of the day, I don’t see a world where any new Super Smash Bros. game, remake or not, is going to please everyone. There are simply too many variables and too high a risk that the player base will be overly scattered, resulting in fewer than expected sales and a much less happy community in the end. The hope is, though, that if we do see a Super Smash Bros. Melee remake, it brings back all those iconic quirks and retains the soul that has kept the competitive scene alive for over two decades.


Super Smash Bros. Melee Tag Page Cover Art

Super Smash Bros. Melee

Systems

super greyscale 8-bit logo

Released

December 3, 2001

ESRB

T For Teen due to Comic Mischief, Mild Violence

Publisher(s)

Nintendo

Engine

Havok

  • walmart

  • amazon app icon-1


Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related News

Ocarina of Time Remake Just Pulled Off a Huge Sales Feat

Ocarina of Time Remake Just Pulled Off a Huge Sales Feat

19 November 2026
Popular Animal Crossing Figures Are Returning

Popular Animal Crossing Figures Are Returning

19 November 2026
Switch 2 Already Has 4 Open World Exclusives Officially Confirmed for 2027

Switch 2 Already Has 4 Open World Exclusives Officially Confirmed for 2027

18 November 2026
Pokemon Champions Officially Confirms First Balance Patch for December 2

Pokemon Champions Officially Confirms First Balance Patch for December 2

18 November 2026
Editors Picks
More Mass Layoffs At Ubisoft Underway, Affecting Two Of Its Biggest Studios

More Mass Layoffs At Ubisoft Underway, Affecting Two Of Its Biggest Studios

19 November 2026
CNN Calls GTA 6 The ‘Most Intense Version Of Pac-Man’

CNN Calls GTA 6 The ‘Most Intense Version Of Pac-Man’

19 November 2026
Mass Effect 5 Is Canceled, but Ex-BioWare RPG Exodus Has One Thing Shepard Never Had

Mass Effect 5 Is Canceled, but Ex-BioWare RPG Exodus Has One Thing Shepard Never Had

19 November 2026
WoW: Forever Wants To Get Rid Of The Idea Of “BiS” Gear

WoW: Forever Wants To Get Rid Of The Idea Of “BiS” Gear

19 November 2026
Top Articles
GTA 6’s Pop And Classic Rock Radio Stations Contain 150 Songs, More Than All Of Vice City’s Radio Stations Combined News

GTA 6’s Pop And Classic Rock Radio Stations Contain 150 Songs, More Than All Of Vice City’s Radio Stations Combined

By News Room
GTA 6 Dog Who Saves You Is Seemingly Based On A Very Cool Real-Life Dog News

GTA 6 Dog Who Saves You Is Seemingly Based On A Very Cool Real-Life Dog

By News Room
Cyberleek Is Threatening To Unleash Chaos Again After Allegedly Tossing An Xbox Build Of GTA 6 Onto The Internet News

Cyberleek Is Threatening To Unleash Chaos Again After Allegedly Tossing An Xbox Build Of GTA 6 Onto The Internet

By News Room
Best in Gaming
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo YouTube
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2026 Best in Gaming. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.